
Seasonal Doesn't Mean Contractor: How to Pay Your Christmas Light Crew
It's November. The mowers are put away and the ladders are out. If you run a lawn care company, there's a good chance you're also in the Christmas light business for the next eight weeks, and you need a few extra hands to make it work.
So you bring on a couple of guys for the season. They'll be gone by mid-January. You pay them every Friday by Venmo, and in QuickBooks the payments go to "Contract Labor." Seems reasonable. They're temporary, right?
Here's the catch: how long someone works for you doesn't decide whether they're a contractor or an employee. Neither does the account you put them in, or what you both agreed to call it. A seasonal worker can absolutely be an employee. A lot of them are.
What actually decides it
The IRS looks at the working relationship as a whole, and it groups the evidence into three buckets.
Behavioral control. Do you decide how, when and where the work gets done? If you set the schedule, assign the houses, train people on your install method and check their work, that points toward employee.
Financial control. Who carries the costs and the risk? A true contractor usually supplies their own tools and equipment, can make or lose money on a job, and works for other customers too. If you supply the truck, the ladders, the lights and the clips, and you pay by the hour, that points toward employee.
The relationship. Is the work a core part of what your business sells? Is there an expectation that they'll keep showing up? Installing lights for a lights company is about as core as it gets.
No single answer settles it. The overall picture does. If you're truly unsure, the IRS will make the call for you on Form SS-8, and Oklahoma's agencies can apply their own tests for unemployment and workers' comp.
Running the test on a typical light crew
Here's how that usually plays out for a seasonal installer compared with someone who really is in business for themselves.
Question | Typical seasonal crew member | Independent installer |
|---|---|---|
Who sets the schedule and route? | You do | They do, around their own clients |
Whose truck, ladders and lights? | Yours | Theirs |
How are they paid? | Hourly or a day rate | A bid or price per job |
Can they lose money on a job? | No | Yes |
Do they work for other companies? | Not really | Yes, and they market themselves |
Do they have their own business, insurance and W-9? | Usually not | Yes |
If your crew lands mostly in the middle column, they look like employees. Seasonal ones, but employees.
Four things that don't change the answer
"They're only here for the season." Short-term work is still work. Payroll handles seasonal employees all the time, and you can let them go in January like anyone else.
"They asked to be paid on a 1099." Plenty of workers prefer it. But you can't agree your way out of the actual relationship, and if it goes wrong, the business is the one on the hook.
"I paid them less than $2,000." Starting with 2026 payments, you generally don't have to file a 1099-NEC for a contractor you paid less than $2,000. That's a reporting rule. It doesn't decide who is a contractor in the first place. If the person was an employee, payroll rules applied from the first dollar.
"I put it in Contract Labor." Your chart of accounts tells you where a cost shows up on your Profit and Loss. It doesn't tell the IRS what kind of worker you had. The label follows the classification, not the other way around.
Why it matters
When an employee gets treated as a contractor, nobody withholds their income tax, the employer half of Social Security and Medicare goes unpaid, and federal and state unemployment taxes get skipped. If the IRS or the state reclassifies them later, the business can owe those taxes plus penalties and interest.
The bigger risk on a light crew is simpler: people fall off ladders. If an injured worker should have been covered by workers' comp and wasn't, that cost can land on you directly. A rooftop in December is a bad place to find out.
What a clean season looks like
Decide before the first shift, not at tax time. Walk through the three buckets above for each role.
Run seasonal employees through payroll. Set them up as employees, pay them hourly, and let them go when the season ends. Their wages go to payroll expense, not Contract Labor.
Keep real contractors documented. Get a W-9 before the first payment, keep the invoice or bid, and turn on 1099 tracking for that vendor.
Use Contract Labor for what it's for. Actual outside businesses: another installer you subcontract a big job to, or a staffing agency that employs the workers itself.
The short version
Seasonal is about when someone works. Contractor or employee is about how they work. Mixing up the two is one of the most common things we see with companies that do their own books, and it's an honest mistake. It's also much easier to set up right in November than to untangle in April.
If you're not sure how your crew should be set up, ask your CPA before the season gets busy. If you'd like someone to keep the books straight once you've decided, that's what we do.
This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Worker classification depends on your specific facts.



